Baku Rejects French Criticism over Nagorno-Karabakh, Armenian Detainees and Displacement
On 19 November, Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry spokesperson Aykhan Hajizada from French officials concerning Azerbaijan’s September 2023 military operation in Nagorno-Karabakh, the prosecution of former Armenian officials and other humanitarian and cultural heritage issues. Hajizada characterised France’s position as selective, one-sided and politically motivated, arguing that its approach undermined rather than advanced the Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process. The response addressed allegations raised by Nicolas Forissier, France’s Minister Delegate for Foreign Trade and Economic Attractiveness, as well as concerns expressed by the French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs in its replies to questions from a French parliamentarian.
Regarding the September 2023 operation, the Azerbaijani MFA maintained that the measures were intended to end what it described as the illegal military presence and activities of Armenian armed forces and affiliated structures in Azerbaijan’s internationally recognised territory, restore constitutional order and re-establish the country’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. The ministry argued that the operation complied with international law, including relevant provisions of the UN Charter. It rejected attempts to frame the operation as a violation of international law, citing the preceding decades of occupation, alleged ethnic cleansing and systematic violations of the rights of hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis.
On the issue of Armenian detainees, Baku denied the description of individuals prosecuted or convicted in Azerbaijan as arbitrarily detained. The MFA stated that those held accountable faced allegations or convictions involving serious offences, including war crimes, crimes against humanity and terrorism. Their cases, according to the ministry, had been handled under Azerbaijani national legislation and the country's applicable international obligations. It also characterised external calls for the release of individuals convicted of serious war crimes as incompatible with the rule of law.
The Azerbaijani MFA also dismissed allegations of the destruction or deliberate alteration of Armenian cultural and religious heritage. It identified the protection and restoration of cultural heritage sites in territories previously under Armenian control as an ongoing national priority. At the same time, the ministry called attention to what it described as extensive destruction and appropriation of Azerbaijani cultural and religious heritage during the decades-long occupation, including mosques, cemeteries and historical monuments. Hajizada further emphasised the rights of hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis displaced from their homes in Armenia and the formerly occupied territories of Azerbaijan. Their right to return in safety and dignity, the ministry maintained, should receive equal consideration alongside other humanitarian concerns. Baku argued that selective treatment of displacement and humanitarian issues weakened the credibility of international appeals concerning human rights and international law.
The response also broadened the dispute to France's domestic record. The Azerbaijani spokesperson accused the French government of judging the internal affairs of other countries while failing to address concerns within France itself. These included the alleged excessive use of force by French police against demonstrators, including minors, serious injuries during student protests, and investigations into alleged police misconduct. The MFA also referred to ongoing trials and corruption investigations involving French political figures, including parliamentarians, questioning the transparency, public accountability and integrity of French institutions. It called on Paris to abandon a biased approach and refrain from interference in Azerbaijan's internal affairs.